SECTION 01

Overload Trip Classes: 10A, 10, 20 & 30 Defined

Thermal overload protective devices are categorised by standard Trip Classes governed by BS EN 60947-4-1 Table 2 (Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Contactors and motor-starters). The trip class defines the maximum tripping time in seconds when the motor is subjected to a symmetrical locked-rotor current of 7.2 times its full-load current rating (7.2x Ir) from cold ambient conditions.

Trip ClassTripping Time at 1.05x IrTripping Time at 1.20x IrTripping Time at 1.50x IrTripping Time at 7.20x IrTypical Industrial Application
Class 10ANo trip (> 2 hours)Trips in < 2 hoursTrips in < 2 minutes2 s ≤ t ≤ 10 sSubmersible borehole pumps, hermetic refrigeration compressors, low-inertia servo drives.
Class 10No trip (> 2 hours)Trips in < 2 hoursTrips in < 4 minutes4 s ≤ t ≤ 10 sStandard general-purpose UK industrial motors, clean water centrifugal pumps, light machine tools.
Class 20No trip (> 2 hours)Trips in < 2 hoursTrips in < 8 minutes6 s ≤ t ≤ 20 sCentrifugal ventilation fans, heavily loaded screw conveyors, positive displacement slurry pumps.
Class 30No trip (> 2 hours)Trips in < 2 hoursTrips in < 12 minutes9 s ≤ t ≤ 30 sHigh-inertia pulverisers, ball mills, rock crushers, shredders with prolonged direct-on-line run-up times.

Selecting the correct trip class is a balance between motor thermal damage and nuisance tripping during acceleration. If a high-inertia exhaust fan requires 16 seconds to reach synchronous speed across a direct-on-line starter, a standard Class 10 overload relay will trip at approximately 8 seconds, preventing the machine from starting.

CRITICAL ERROR: DIALLING UP CURRENT TO PREVENT INERTIA TRIPS

An installer faced with nuisance tripping on a high-inertia fan often dials the current setting dial from 20A up to 28A on a Class 10 relay. While this stops the starting trip, it permanently deprives the motor of overload protection during normal running. If mechanical bearing drag increases full-load current to 24A, the relay will never trip! The motor winding insulation operates in thermal overload continuously until burnout occurs. The correct engineering solution is to install a Class 20 or Class 30 relay correctly set to 20A rated nameplate current.

SECTION 02

Thermal Bimetallic vs Electronic Overload Relays

Motor control panels utilise two primary technologies for overcurrent thermal protection:

1. Traditional Bimetallic Overload Relays

A bimetallic overload relay routes each phase current through a resistive heating element wrapped around a bimetallic strip. Each strip consists of two dissimilar metals bonded together with differing coefficients of thermal expansion (typically invar and brass/nickel-steel). As current flows, I²R heating causes the strip to bend towards a mechanical trip bar.

  • Ambient Temperature Compensation: Standard industrial relays incorporate a fourth, unheated bimetallic strip that deflects in the opposite direction in response to cabinet ambient temperature changes (-20°C to +60°C), ensuring trip thresholds remain consistent.
  • Narrow Current Adjustment Range: Due to physical bimetal heating constraints, each bimetallic relay covers a very narrow adjustment window, typically 1:1.5 (e.g. 10A to 16A), requiring panel builders to stock dozens of distinct catalogue part numbers.
  • High Internal Power Loss: The heater coils dissipate significant thermal energy continuously (typically 4W to 12W per relay), heating the enclosure interior.

2. Solid-State Electronic Overload Relays

Solid-state relays monitor phase currents using integrated current transformers (CTs) coupled to an onboard microprocessor running an internal digital thermal model:

  • Wide 5:1 Setting Range: A single electronic relay model typically spans an extensive setting window (e.g. 4A to 20A or 20A to 100A), drastically reducing spares inventory.
  • Selectable Trip Classes: Trip classes (10A, 10, 20, 30) are selectable via a front rotary DIP switch, allowing instant commissioning adjustments without replacing hardware.
  • Negligible Internal Heat: Consumes less than 0.5W, reducing cabinet cooling demands.
  • True Digital Thermal Memory: Tracks motor heating and cooling curves digitally, retaining thermal state across power interruptions.
SECTION 03

The Single-Phasing Hazard & Differential Phase-Loss Mechanics

Single-phasing occurs when one of the three supply lines to a running three-phase motor is severed (caused by a blown upstream fuse, broken overhead line, or high-resistance pitted contactor pole).

When an operating three-phase motor loses one phase, it does not stop immediately. The rotating magnetic field becomes elliptical, but rotor inertia keeps the shaft spinning. However, the stator electrical conditions become catastrophic:

  • To maintain mechanical shaft power, the remaining two healthy phases must draw significantly higher current.
  • External line current typically increases by 1.15x to 1.30x of full load.
  • In a Delta-connected stator winding, current distribution is severely asymmetrical. While two winding phases carry single-phase branch current, the third winding phase connected directly across the surviving line-to-line voltage carries 1.73x to 2.0x of its normal rated phase current!
  • Because heating power varies with current squared (I²), the stressed winding experiences 300% to 400% of its normal thermal dissipation. Stator insulation will carbonise and short-circuit within 3 to 10 minutes.
BS EN 60947-4-1 CLAUSE 8.2.1.5.2 PHASE-LOSS MANDATE

Standard non-differential bimetallic relays only trip when total line current exceeds the thermal threshold. Under 70% mechanical load, single-phasing causes line current to reach only 1.05x full load. A standard overload will never trip, while the internal delta winding burns out!

Therefore, BS EN 60947-4-1 Clause 8.2.1.5.2 mandates phase-loss sensitivity. Bimetallic relays must incorporate an internal differential slide bar mechanism. When all three bimetals deflect together under balanced load, the upper and lower slide bars move in parallel without tilting the trip pivot. If one phase is lost, its cold bimetal holds back the lower slide bar while the two hot bimetals push the upper slide bar forward. The mechanical differential action tilts the internal trip lever, accelerating the trip mechanism to disconnect within less than 20 minutes from hot state (and < 3 seconds on electronic relays).

SECTION 04

Embedded Stator PTC Thermistors & PT100 Sensors

Current-measuring overload relays suffer from a fundamental blind spot: they infer motor temperature from current, assuming normal ambient cooling. They cannot detect motor overheating caused by:

  • Blocked Cowl Vents: Heavy dust, paper pulp, or plastic film choking the external fan cowl.
  • High Ambient Temperature: Motor installed near industrial furnaces, boilers, or inside unventilated machine enclosures exceeding 40°C.
  • Repeated Rapid Starting / Jogging: Multiple consecutive direct-on-line starts where locked-rotor heating accumulates faster than the cabinet relay can track.
  • Low-Speed VFD Operation: Reduced airflow from the shaft-mounted fan at low drive frequencies.

1. DIN 44081 / DIN 44082 PTC Thermistors

Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC) thermistors are miniature ceramic semiconductor beads (doped barium titanate) embedded directly into the end-turn windings of each stator phase during motor manufacture. Three beads are wired internally in series:

  • Nominal Actuating Temperature (NAT): Calibrated during motor manufacture to match insulation class (e.g. 150°C NAT for Class F motors).
  • Extremely Sharp Resistance Knee: From cold up to NAT - 20°C, total resistance of the series triplet remains low (Rcold ≤ 750 Ω, typically 150 Ω to 300 Ω).
  • Trigger Threshold: Within a narrow 5°C band around NAT, resistance increases exponentially by several orders of magnitude, passing 1,650 Ω (the standard trip threshold in DIN EN 60947-8 thermistor evaluation relays) and exceeding 4,000 Ω at NAT + 5°C.
  • Fail-Safe Behaviour: A broken sensor lead presents infinite resistance (open-circuit), instantly triggering a safe shutdown. A short-circuited lead is detected as abnormally low resistance (< 15 Ω), initiating a sensor wire fault alarm.

2. Linear PT100 Resistance Temperature Detectors (RTDs)

PT100 sensors consist of a precision platinum wire or thin-film resistor exhibiting a highly linear positive temperature coefficient governed by BS EN 60751:

R(T) = R_0 × (1 + A × T + B × T²) ≈ 100 Ω × (1 + 0.00385 × T)
  • Continuous Temperature Telemetry: At 0°C, R = 100.0 Ω; at 100°C, R = 138.5 Ω; at 150°C, R = 157.3 Ω. Resistance increases linearly at approximately 0.385 Ω/°C.
  • Predictive Maintenance: Unlike PTC thermistors which act as binary thermal trip switches, PT100 RTDs provide continuous analog temperature readouts to PLC analog input cards or SCADA systems, enabling trend analysis, early warning alarms at 130°C, and thermal runaway tracking before trip thresholds are breached.
  • 3-Wire and 4-Wire Configurations: Long cable runs between motor and control panel add lead resistance. A 4-wire PT100 circuit eliminates lead wire resistance errors through Kelvin bridge cancellation.
SECTION 05

VFD Thermal Derating & Inverter-Duty Motors

Variable frequency drives present unique thermal challenges that render traditional bimetallic overload relays ineffective:

Cooling Fan Degradation: Standard totally enclosed fan-cooled (TEFC / IC 411) motors utilise a cooling fan mounted directly to the rotor shaft. Airflow varies linearly with shaft speed, and cooling heat transfer capability varies approximately with the square of speed. Operating a standard motor at 20 Hz (40% speed) reduces cooling effectiveness to less than 20% of nominal. Continuous rated torque at low frequencies causes rapid thermal runaway.

Engineering Solutions for Inverter-Driven Motors

  1. Forced Ventilation (Blower Cooling - IC 416): Fit an auxiliary forced cooling blower fan powered by an independent 230V/400V supply that runs continuously at full speed, delivering 100% cooling airflow regardless of main rotor speed.
  2. Direct PTC Thermistor Monitoring: Mandatory connection of stator PTC thermistors directly into the VFD control terminals or a dedicated DIN rail safety relay (DIN EN 60947-8).
  3. Electronic Thermal Memory in VFD: Enable the drive's internal I²t digital thermal protection curve, programmed specifically for low-speed cooling derating per the motor manufacturer's speed-torque envelope.
SECTION 06

Master Verification Procedure: Motor Overload Protection

Before commissioning or returning a motor starter to service following maintenance, verify the overload protective circuit against the following engineering verification criteria:

Phase / StepAction & Test MethodStatutory / Standard RefAcceptance CriteriaNon-Conformance Action
01. Nameplate Current SettingVerify overload relay current dial setting matches motor rating plate full-load current (FLC / Ir) for the operational connection (Star or Delta).BS EN 60947-4-1 §5.7
BS 7671 Reg 433.1
Dial set strictly to 1.00x motor nameplate FLC (or FLC / √3 if mounted inside delta loop).Correct setting. Never dial above nameplate FLC to overcome nuisance inertia starting trips.
02. Trip Class MatchingConfirm relay trip class (10A, 10, 20, 30) matches load acceleration run-up time at locked rotor (7.2x Ir).BS EN 60947-4-1 Table 2
EAWR 1989 Reg 5
Motor reaches full speed in < 80% of relay trip class time. Zero nuisance trips on warm restarts.Replace relay with higher trip class (e.g. upgrade from Class 10 to Class 20/30) while maintaining correct FLC setting.
03. Phase-Loss ActionVerify differential phase-loss mechanism: perform manual mechanical test on relay test slide bar.BS EN 60947-4-1 §8.2.1.5.2
EAWR 1989 Reg 5
Auxiliary 95-96 NC contact opens cleanly; 97-98 NO alarm closes. Mechanism latches in trip state.Reject relay. Replace defective non-differential or seized bimetallic overload unit immediately.
04. Stator PTC TelemetryMeasure resistance across stator PTC thermistor sensor loop terminals using calibrated DMM (≤ 2.5V test voltage).DIN 44081 §4
DIN EN 60947-8
Cold loop resistance between 150 Ω and 750 Ω (per 3-bead triplet). Resistance to PE > 100 MΩ.If R > 1,650 Ω cold: sensor bead broken or shorted to winding. Disconnect and investigate stator core.
05. Relay Trip InjectionInject 3.0x Ir test current using secondary current injection test set across all three poles from cold state.BS EN 60947-4-1 Table 3
BS 7671 Reg 643.10
Relay trips within manufacturer published time-current envelope (typically 12s to 30s for Class 10).Recalibrate electronic unit or replace out-of-tolerance bimetallic overload relay.
06. VFD Auxiliary Blower InterlockVerify forced ventilation blower motor running on VFD installations operating below 30 Hz.BS EN 60034-6 (IC 416)
Supply of Machinery Regs
Blower airflow confirmed; auxiliary contact interlocked into VFD run-permissive circuit.Inhibit VFD start until forced cooling blower is confirmed running via pressure/current sensor.
SECTION 07

Bench Notes: Advanced Thermal & Magnetic Physics

BENCH NOTE 01Arrhenius Chemical Rate Law & The 10°C Insulation Half-Life Rule

The chemical degradation of organic insulating varnish, polyester film, and epoxy resin in stator windings is governed by the Arrhenius Chemical Reaction Rate Law:

k = A × exp(-E_a / (R · T))

Where:

  • k = Chemical reaction degradation rate (oxidation and polymer cross-linking breakdown)
  • A = Pre-exponential frequency factor
  • Ea = Activation energy of the insulation material (typically 0.8 to 1.1 eV for Class F electrical resins)
  • R = Universal gas constant (8.314 J/(mol·K))
  • T = Absolute thermodynamic temperature in Kelvin (K)

The expected functional lifetime (L) of the insulation is inversely proportional to reaction rate (L ∝ 1/k). Taking the ratio of lifetimes between rated design temperature (T1) and elevated temperature (T2):

(L_2 / L_1) = exp[(E_a / R) × ((1 / T_2) - (1 / T_1))] ≈ 2^(-ΔT / 10)

For Class F insulation materials evaluated across the range from 140°C to 180°C, substituting empirical values for Ea/R yields the classical industrial rule of thumb: every 10°C elevation in winding temperature halves the remaining operational life. Operating a 155°C Class F motor continuously at 175°C reduces its expected insulation life from 100,000 hours (approx 11.4 years) to just 25,000 hours (2.85 years).

BENCH NOTE 02Delta Winding Vector Analysis During Single-Phasing (1.73x Proof)

Prove mathematically why single-phasing produces an intolerable 1.73x current surge in one delta phase while external line current registers only a modest 1.15x rise.

Consider a balanced Delta-connected stator. Under normal symmetrical 3-phase conditions:

I_phase = I_line / √3 ≈ 0.577 × I_line

Now assume supply Phase L2 is severed (IL2 = 0). The motor continues running on phases L1 and L3. The delta winding geometry now resolves into two parallel branches connected across single-phase line voltage V13:

  • Branch A: Winding phase U-V and winding phase V-W connected in series across V13. Impedance = 2 × Zphase.
  • Branch B: Winding phase W-U connected directly across V13. Impedance = Zphase.

By current division, Branch B carries exactly twice the current of Branch A (Ibranch B = 2 × Ibranch A). Total line current equals:

I_line(1-phase) = I_branch_A + I_branch_B = 3 × I_branch_A

To deliver the same mechanical shaft torque as rated 3-phase operation, total active power must remain approximately constant:

P_3φ = √3 × V_L × I_L(3φ) × cosφ ⇔ P_1φ = V_L × I_line(1-phase) × cosφ

Equating power reveals:

I_line(1-phase) = √3 × I_L(3φ) ≈ 1.732 × I_L(3φ)

The current through the heavily stressed single delta phase (Branch B) equals:

I_phase(stressed) = (2 / 3) × I_line(1-phase) = (2 / 3) × (√3 × I_L(3φ)) = (2√3 / 3) × (√3 × I_phase(normal)) = 2.0 × I_phase(normal)

At 100% load, the internal winding current doubles (200%), and internal I²R heating power quadruples (2² = 400%). Even at 60% mechanical load, the stressed winding carries 1.73 × Iphase(normal), generating 300% of nominal heat while line current barely reaches 1.15 × Iline. Without differential phase loss mechanics, the motor burns out silently.

BENCH NOTE 03PTC Thermistor Barium Titanate Ferroelectric Curie Physics

The extraordinary non-linear switching behaviour of DIN 44081 PTC thermistors originates from the solid-state physics of polycrystalline doped barium titanate (BaTiO3) ceramic semiconductors.

Below the Curie temperature (TC), the crystal lattice exhibits a tetragonal ferroelectric structure. Spontaneous internal polarisation creates strong electric dipoles along the crystal grain boundaries. This dipole alignment cancels out potential energy barriers between adjacent ceramic grains, allowing conduction electrons to flow freely. The material exhibits low resistivity:

R_cold ≤ 250 Ω (per bead at 25°C)

As the motor winding temperature crosses the Curie point (calibrated by donor dopants such as lead, strontium, or yttrium to precisely match the nominal response temperature NAT):

  1. The crystal lattice undergoes a phase transition from tetragonal to cubic (paraelectric).
  2. Spontaneous ferroelectric polarisation collapses instantly.
  3. Trapped electrons at the grain boundaries form a steep electrostatic double-Schottky barrier.

The grain boundary potential barrier height (ΦB) increases according to the Curie-Weiss law:

ΦB ∝ (1 / εr) ∝ (T - T_C)

Because electrical resistivity depends exponentially on barrier height (ρ ∝ exp(eΦB / (kB T))), resistance increases by a factor of 100 to 1,000 within a tiny temperature span of less than 5°C. This digital step-function provides an unmistakable switching trigger for DIN EN 60947-8 control relays, completely immune to electromagnetic interference or analog drift.

BENCH NOTE 04Solid-State Thermal Memory & Asymmetrical Cooling Time Constants

An electric motor heating profile is characterised by an exponential thermal time constant (τheat), governed by the balance between internal I²R loss generation and convective heat dissipation:

θ(t) = θfinal × (1 - exp(-t / τheat))

Where τheat = Cth × Rth (thermal capacitance of stator copper and iron laminations multiplied by thermal resistance to cooling air). In a typical 45 kW motor running at full load with its cooling fan spinning at 1,480 RPM, τheat is approximately 25 to 35 minutes.

However, when the motor trips on an overload and stops spinning, the shaft-mounted cooling fan halts. Heat transfer switches from forced turbulent convection to slow natural buoyant convection. The cooling time constant at standstill (τcool) increases dramatically:

τcool ≈ (3.5 to 5.0) × τheat ≈ 90 to 150 minutes

A traditional bimetallic overload relay is mounted inside the control cabinet. Its tiny bimetallic strips cool down to ambient in 5 to 10 minutes. If an operator presses the reset button after 10 minutes and restarts the motor, the bimetal is completely cold, but the motor stator core is still sitting at 120°C.

A solid-state electronic overload relay solves this by maintaining an internal microprocessor digital accumulator. The software continuously calculates thermal content (Θ) using the standstill cooling decay model:

Θ(t) = Θtrip × exp(-t / τcool)

The electronic relay inhibits reset until Θ(t) falls below a safe restarting threshold (typically 50% to 60% of rated thermal capacity), guaranteeing that the motor has physically cooled down before facing another locked-rotor inrush transient.

SECTION 08

Statutory Duty Matrix: Motor Overload Protection

Compliance with UK electrical safety legislation requires strict adherence to statutory duties and consensus design standards:

Statutory AuthorityRegulatory RequirementMandatory Engineering ActionDuty Holder Penalty
Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 Regulation 5Strength and capability of electrical equipment to withstand prospective thermal stresses.Mandatory installation of overload devices correctly set to motor full-load current (FLC); prevent conductor thermal breakdown.Criminal prosecution; unlimited statutory fines; personal liability for engineering managers.
BS EN 60947-4-1:2019 Clause 8.2.1.5.2Phase-loss sensitivity: relays must trip within accelerated time under single-phase supply unbalance.Specify relays with differential slide bar action or solid-state negative-sequence detection on all 3-phase starters.Revocation of machine CE/UKCA mark; enforcement notices issued by HSE.
BS 7671:2018+A4:2026 Section 433 & 552Protection against overload currents in motor circuits.Overload protective device operating current I2 must not exceed 1.45x conductor current-carrying capacity Iz.Unsatisfactory EICR report; Code C2 defect recorded; commercial insurance invalidation.
DIN EN 60947-8:2013Control units for built-in thermal protection (PTC) in rotating electrical machines.Install certified thermistor evaluation relays tripping at 1,650 Ω and resetting at 750 Ω for severe duty drives.Motor warranty cancellation by manufacturer upon stator burnout.
SECTION 09

Interactive Workbench & Visual Lab Companions

Calculate motor full-load currents, size direct-on-line and star-delta starters, and simulate thermal-magnetic trip curves using our verified interactive instruments: