Direct EU 2024/573 Application
Under the Windsor Framework, Northern Ireland is directly bound by EU Regulation 2024/573 on fluorinated greenhouse gases. The statutory prohibition on placing new medium-voltage electrical switchgear up to and including 24kV with GWP ≥ 1 onto the market came into force on 1 January 2026. Transmission voltage phase-outs (up to 52kV) follow on 1 January 2030. Enforcement is conducted by the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA).
Assimilated EU Law & UK Secondary Legislation
In Great Britain (England, Scotland, and Wales), F-gas controls operate under assimilated EU Regulation 517/2014 (via the REUL Act 2023) and the Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases Regulations 2015 (SI 2015/310 as amended). Following consultations by Defra, the Scottish Government, and the Welsh Government, GB policy intends to align with phase-out milestones, but domestic secondary legislation has not yet enacted a hard 1 January 2026 ban for new ≤ 24kV switchgear. Operators remain bound by existing leak-checking, recovery, and technician certification duties enforced by the Environment Agency (EA), SEPA, and Natural Resources Wales (NRW).
1. UK and European F-Gas Statutory Milestones
Sulphur Hexafluoride (SF6) is an extraordinarily potent greenhouse gas. In statutory UK and European reporting, its Global Warming Potential (GWP) is legally benchmarked at 22,800 times that of CO2 over a 100-year horizon (IPCC Fourth Assessment Report, AR4). The more recent IPCC Sixth Assessment Report (AR6) evaluates the 100-year GWP of SF6 at 24,300, with an atmospheric persistence exceeding 3,200 years.
Under European Union F-Gas Regulation (EU) 2024/573 (in force directly in Northern Ireland under the Windsor Framework) and aligned domestic secondary legislation being prepared by Defra and the devolved administrations for Great Britain, statutory prohibition milestones govern the placing on the market of new electrical switchgear:
| Implementation Date | Voltage Scope | Statutory Prohibition | Primary Technical Alternatives |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 January 2026 | ≤ 24 kV Distribution networks, 11kV primary and secondary RMUs | In force in Northern Ireland (EU 2024/573 Article 13(9)(a)). In Great Britain, subject to forthcoming secondary legislation following joint Defra consultation. Prohibits putting into operation new switchgear using fluorinated greenhouse gases with GWP ≥ 1 (unless GWP < 10 where strictly necessary to meet technical safety specifications). | Vacuum Interrupters in natural origin gases (Dry Technical Air, Clean Air, Nitrogen) or Solid Dielectric (such as Schneider Premset, Siemens blue GIS, ABB UniGear). |
| 1 January 2028 | > 52 kV to ≤ 145 kV (≤ 50 kA) Grid transmission substations (66kV and 132kV) | Prohibition on putting into operation new switchgear using fluorinated greenhouse gases with GWP ≥ 1 across EU/NI (EU 2024/573 Article 13(9)(b)), with aligned GB adoption proposed. | Natural origin gas vacuum circuit breakers and advanced synthetic air GIS. Fluoronitrile mixtures (such as GE Vernova g3, GWP < 350) permitted where derogation criteria under Article 13 are satisfied. |
| 1 January 2030 | > 24 kV to ≤ 52 kV 33kV distribution substations and wind farm collector arrays | Prohibition on putting into operation new switchgear using fluorinated greenhouse gases with GWP ≥ 1 across EU/NI (EU 2024/573 Article 13(9)(c)), with aligned GB adoption proposed. | Vacuum interrupters with natural origin gases (synthetic dry air, clean air, nitrogen) or solid insulation. Fluoronitrile mixtures (g3) remain applicable where no F-gas-free alternative can meet technical requirements. |
| 1 January 2032 | > 145 kV or > 50 kA Supergrid transmission (275kV and 400kV) or heavy generation | Prohibition on high-voltage transmission switchgear with GWP ≥ 1 (EU 2024/573 Article 13(9)(d)), pending international pilot trials and statutory readiness reviews. | Advanced clean air combinations and high-capacity vacuum circuit breakers, alongside transitional mixtures where permitted by statutory derogations. |
2. Alternative Technologies: SF6 vs Vacuum vs Technical Air vs g3
For 11kV distribution switchgear (≤ 24kV), vacuum interrupters in natural origin gases (clean air, dry air, nitrogen) or solid insulation are the primary compliant alternatives post-2026. Fluoronitrile gas mixtures (such as g3, with GWP < 350) represent alternatives for higher voltage classes (> 24kV) or under statutory derogations where no F-gas-free alternative can meet technical requirements:
| Engineering Parameter | Legacy SF6 Puffer | Vacuum in Dry Air / Clean Air | Fluoronitrile Mixture (g3, > 24kV / Derogation) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arc Quenching Medium | Pressurised SF6 gas (1.3 to 1.5 bar) | Hermetically sealed Vacuum bottle (< 10⁻⁷ mbar) | Fluoronitrile (C4-FN) + CO2 + O2 gas mixture |
| Global Warming Potential (GWP) | 22,800 (AR4 statutory) / 24,300 (AR6) | 0 (Zero GWP) | < 350 (99% reduction vs SF6) |
| Electrical Endurance | 2,000 to 5,000 operations (contact burn requires gas handling) | 10,000 to 30,000 operations (sealed for life, zero maintenance) | 5,000 to 10,000 operations |
| Arcing Byproducts & Toxicity | Highly Toxic: HF, SO2, S2F10 gases and corrosive metal fluoride dust | Non-Toxic: Pure metallic vapour condenses harmlessly on internal shield | Lower toxicity than SF6; CO and fluorinated byproducts form under high-energy arcing, requiring certified handling and PPE |
| Low-Temperature Liquefaction | Liquefies at high pressures below -10°C (requires tank heaters) | Unaffected down to -50°C (pure dry air / N2 / O2) | Formulated for -25°C or -30°C operations without heating |
| Transient Overvoltage (Chopping) | Very low current chopping; gentle interruption | Chopping current 2 to 4A on light inductive loads (fit surge arresters on dry transformers) | Comparable to SF6 characteristics |
3. Statutory Obligations for Existing SF6 Switchgear
Existing SF6 installations are not subject to mandatory early decommissioning. You may operate existing equipment until its natural end of operational life. However, asset owners and duty holders (under EAWR 1989 Regulation 4(1) for construction and Regulation 4(2) for maintenance, both to prevent danger so far as is reasonably practicable, and UK F-Gas Statutory Instruments) are subject to stringent operational rules:
Under Article 6(1) of assimilated EU Regulation 517/2014 (in Great Britain via the REUL Act 2023) and Article 7 of EU 2024/573 (in Northern Ireland), operators of equipment that is required to be checked for leaks under Article 4(1) of assimilated 517/2014 or Article 5 of EU 2024/573 (threshold 5 tonnes CO2 equivalent or more, equating to 0.22 kg SF6) must maintain statutory equipment records detailing:
- Quantity and type of gas installed in each apparatus.
- Quantities added during maintenance, top-up, or commissioning operations.
- Whether quantities installed have been recycled or reclaimed, including the name and address of the recycling facility.
- Identity of the certified service company and qualified technician holding certification under Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2066.
- Dates and results of all mandatory leak inspections.
- Quantities of gas recovered during servicing or decommissioning.
Threshold Mass = 5,000 kg CO2e / 22,800 GWP (IPCC AR4 Statutory Baseline) = 0.2193 kg ≈ 0.22 kg SF6Scope of duty: Where electrical switchgear meets the Article 4(1) third subparagraph points (a) to (c) exemption (in GB) or Article 5(2) (in NI), statutory Article 6 logbooks (Article 7 in NI) are not legally mandated. However, maintaining comprehensive asset logs remains strong industry best practice under DNO specifications and client asset management. Statutory recovery upon decommissioning (Article 8 in both regulations) and certified personnel requirements (Article 10) apply to all switchgear regardless of charge size.
Under Article 4 of assimilated EU 517/2014 (in GB) and Article 5 of EU 2024/573 (in Northern Ireland), statutory baseline leak testing frequencies are governed by total carbon dioxide equivalent charge:
- Hermetically sealed equipment: Exempt from routine leak checks if charge is < 10 t CO2e (< 0.44 kg SF6) and labelled as hermetically sealed.
- 5 to 50 t CO2e (0.22 to 2.19 kg SF6): Mandatory inspection every 12 months (or 24 months if fitted with calibrated continuous leak detection).
- 50 to 500 t CO2e (2.19 to 21.93 kg SF6): Mandatory inspection every 6 months (or 12 months with continuous leak detection system).
- > 500 t CO2e (> 21.93 kg SF6): Mandatory inspection every 3 months (or 6 months with continuous leak detection system).
Switchgear Exemption (Article 4(1) Third Subparagraph in GB / Article 5(2) in NI): In practical high-voltage distribution networks, electrical switchgear is specifically exempt from routine periodic leak testing under Article 4(1), third subparagraph, points (a) to (c) of assimilated EU 517/2014 (and Article 5(2) of EU 2024/573), if it satisfies at least one of the following statutory conditions:
- It has a tested leakage rate of less than 0.1% per year as certified by the manufacturer and is labelled accordingly.
- It is equipped with an electrical pressure or density monitoring device (such as temperature-compensated density switches connected to SCADA or telemetry).
- It contains less than 6 kg of electrical switchgear fluorinated greenhouse gas charge.
Under the Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 (Regulation 16) and UK F-Gas regulations:
- Personnel recovering, handling, or topping up SF6 from electrical switchgear must hold a valid high-voltage switchgear F-Gas qualification under Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2066 (or assimilated UK equivalent qualification). City & Guilds 2079 applies to refrigeration and heat pump systems, not electrical switchgear.
- Personnel working on high-voltage equipment must also hold appropriate company safety rules authorisation (such as Senior Authorised Person or Competent Person status).
- Direct venting of SF6 into the atmosphere during maintenance, gas sampling, or decommissioning is a criminal offence carrying unlimited fines under UK environmental law.
- Recovery cylinders must be tracked with statutory Hazardous Waste Consignment Notes (HWCN) in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland (Hazardous Waste Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2005), or Special Waste Consignment Notes in Scotland, consigned to registered disposal facilities.
When an internal electrical arc occurs inside SF6 switchgear, the intense thermal energy breaks down the SF6 molecule into toxic byproducts:
- Thionyl fluoride (SOF2) & Sulphur dioxide (SO2): Acrid, suffocating gases causing immediate respiratory distress and pulmonary edema.
- Hydrofluoric Acid (HF): Extremely corrosive acid that penetrates skin and attacks bone tissue.
- Disulphur decafluoride (S2F10): Highly toxic gas with toxicity comparable to phosgene.
- White Fluoride Powder: Metal fluoride dusts (AlF3, CuF2) deposited inside tanks. Duty holders must conduct a site-specific COSHH risk assessment. PPE must be selected in accordance with the assessment and company safety rules, typically requiring chemical barrier suits, specialised HF-resistant gloves (such as butyl or heavy neoprene), and appropriate respiratory protection (positive-pressure self-contained breathing apparatus if gas concentrations or oxygen levels are unverified, or full-face respirators with ABEK2-P3 filters for low dust exposures).
4. Asset Replacement & Specification Decision Flow
For new substations, private network replacements, and factory expansions, follow this statutory specification path:
Specification Stage (Pre-Procurement)
Check operating voltage and procurement timing. If ≤ 24kV and the equipment is to be placed on the market after 1 January 2026, contracts in Northern Ireland must specify F-gas-free technology (vacuum circuit breaker in dry air, clean air, or solid insulation). Pre-prohibition stock already placed on the market before 1 January 2026 may still be installed and commissioned. GB specifications should align with forthcoming secondary legislation. Verify supplier technical declarations for insulating and breaking media to confirm GWP < 1 in addition to standard EN 62271-200 mechanical and electrical ratings.
Transient Overvoltage Risk Assessment
When pairing modern vacuum switchgear with dry-type resin cast transformers or high-efficiency motors, evaluate switching transient overvoltages. Fit zinc-oxide (ZnO) surge arresters or RC snubber circuits directly at the transformer/motor HV terminals to dampen vacuum contact chopping reflections.
Asset Register & F-Gas Audit
Conduct a site survey of all legacy SF6 gear. Record the exact gas charge (kg) from rating plates into your site asset register. Equipment containing 5 tonnes CO2 equivalent or more (0.22 kg SF6) engages statutory leak inspection and logbook obligations under assimilated EU 517/2014 Article 4(1) and Article 6(1) in GB (EU 2024/573 Articles 5 and 7 in NI), unless exempt under Article 4(1) third subparagraph points (a) to (c) in GB (or Article 5(2) in NI) by having certified leakage under 0.1% per year and labelled, continuous pressure or density monitoring fitted, or a charge under 6 kg. Units exceeding 6 kg without density monitoring or certified low-leakage labelling require periodic leak inspections.
Decommissioning & Disposal Plan
Never permit scrap metal merchants to remove switchgear containing SF6. Engage a licensed hazardous waste contractor to pump down the chamber to < 20 mbar residual pressure and issue a Hazardous Waste Consignment Note (England, Wales, and Northern Ireland) or Special Waste Consignment Note (Scotland) before mechanical dismantling.