The EICR Coding Decision Framework: Demystifying C1, C2, C3 & FI
Electrical Installation Condition Reports (EICRs) are among the most scrutinised legal and technical documents in the UK electrical contracting industry. Inconsistent classification of defects damages client relationships, creates severe landlord compliance liabilities, and exposes inspectors to negligence claims. This framework establishes an authoritative classification methodology aligned strictly with Electrical Safety First Best Practice Guide 4 (BPG 4 Issue 7), IET Guidance Note 3 (GN3), and BS 7671 Appendix 6.
An Electrical Installation Condition Report (EICR) is an engineering safety assessment of an existing installation against the safety principles of current standards.An EICR is not a snagging list or an order to retrospectively upgrade installations that remain safe in service.Defect coding carries direct legal consequences under the Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 and triggers a strict 28-day statutory remedial window with civil penalties up to £30,000 under the Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020.
Immediate risk of fatal shock or fire. Live conductors exposed to touch. Oral notification, isolate on site, and issue written Danger Notice.
Latent danger requiring a secondary fault to cause harm. Missing main bonding, Zs > max limit, open CPC. Overall Unsatisfactory.
Safety cannot be verified without intrusive investigation. Automatically Unsatisfactory. PRS 2020 mandates resolution within 28 days.
Non-compliance with current edition, but safe in service. No RCD on buried cables >50mm, absence of SPDs. Report remains Satisfactory.
EICR Defect Classification Logic & Section D Outcome Gate
The decision to classify an observation rests on a single physical principle:Does the condition present an immediate risk of shock, fire, or burns, or does it require a secondary fault to cause danger?The diagram below establishes the decision boundary and its impact on the Section D overall assessment:
Code C1: Danger Present (Immediate Action Required)
Definition: Persons using the installation are at direct risk of electric shock, burns, or fire without another fault occurring. The physical barrier preventing contact with live parts exceeding 50 V AC has failed completely, or active arcing and carbonisation are taking place.
- Immediate Oral Notification: Verbally inform the person ordering the work, site dutyholder, or occupier immediately upon discovering the hazard.
- Isolate or Make Safe with Permission: With the client's consent, isolate the dangerous circuit or component immediately, or apply temporary guarding to prevent contact.
- Issue Formal Written Danger Notification: Hand over a formal written 'Danger Notification' document on site before departure, recording the hazard and action taken.
- Record C1 on Report Schedule: Formally document the observation on the EICR schedule, guaranteeing an overall Unsatisfactory assessment.
• Missing blanks on consumer unit allowing direct finger contact with live busbars.
• Smashed socket faceplates with bare live terminals accessible.
• Conductive enclosure live due to active, uncleared phase fault.
Leaving an unmitigated C1 hazard without written notification exposes the inspector and employer to immediate prosecution under Section 3 of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.
Code C2: Potentially Dangerous (Urgent Remedial Action)
Definition: The defect does not present immediate danger under normal conditions, but will result in danger upon the occurrence of a secondary fault or foreseeable operating event. A single C2 observation automatically mandates an overall Unsatisfactory assessment on Section D of the report.
• Absence of reliable earthing facility or main protective bonding to incoming metallic gas/water services.
• Earth fault loop impedance (Zs) exceeding maximum tabulated disconnection limit.
• Absence of 30 mA RCD on socket-outlets reasonably expected to feed outdoor portable tools.
Under the Private Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020, landlords must complete remedial work within 28 days (or shorter if specified by the inspector) and obtain written proof of compliance.
Code FI: Further Investigation Required
Definition: The inspector observes evidence indicating an underlying safety hazard, but the agreed extent and limitations of the inspection prevent full verification without intrusive disassembly.
Inaccessible rooms, high-level fittings, or locked cupboards belong strictly in the Extent and Limitations section, never as FI codes. Code FI is reserved strictly for genuine abnormal test findings (such as severe insulation degradation across a whole bank of circuits, or a suspect ring interconnection) that cannot be completed within sampling. Under both BPG 4 and PRS Regulations 2020, an FI code renders the report Unsatisfactory and triggers the mandatory 28-day investigation clock.
Code C3: Improvement Recommended (Safe in Service)
Definition: Non-compliance with the current edition of BS 7671 (BS 7671:2018+A4:2026) that does not present immediate or potential danger. It highlights areas where modern standards offer superior safety, but the existing installation remains safe for continued service.
An installation displaying multiple Code C3 observations and zero C1, C2, or FI observations is officially Satisfactory. Dutyholders and landlords are under zero statutory legal obligation to implement C3 recommendations.
Industry Defect Classification Schedule (12 Core Scenarios)
This schedule reflects consensus rulings from Electrical Safety First Best Practice Guide 4 (Issue 7), IET Guidance Note 3, and BS 7671:
| Observed Installation Condition | Code | Engineering & Safety Rationale | Standard Clause |
|---|---|---|---|
| Missing blanks on consumer unit enclosure | CODE C1 | Exposed live copper busbar or terminal accessible to touch (IP2X / IPXXB breach). | Reg 416.2.1 BPG 4 Item 1.1 |
| Exposed live conductor insulation stripped back outside accessory | CODE C1 | Direct shock hazard accessible without a tool. Immediate danger present. | Reg 416.1 BPG 4 Item 1.2 |
| Absence of main protective bonding to incoming metallic gas or water service | CODE C2 | Extraneous conductive part can introduce true earth potential into premises during external fault. | Reg 411.3.1.2 BPG 4 Item 2.1 |
| Measured loop impedance Zs exceeds maximum tabulated limit (No RCD) | CODE C2 | Protective device cannot achieve required disconnection time (0.4s) under earth fault. | Table 41.3 Reg 411.4.5 |
| Socket-outlet reasonably expected to supply portable equipment outdoors without 30 mA RCD | CODE C2 | Severe shock hazard in outdoor conditions where user is in direct contact with true earth. | Reg 411.3.3 BPG 4 Item 2.4 |
| Absence of circuit protective conductor (CPC) on Class I metal lighting fittings | CODE C2 | Exposed conductive parts become live upon internal insulation fault without tripping breaker. | Reg 411.3.1.1 BPG 4 Item 2.2 |
| Abnormal insulation resistance reading across group of circuits that cannot be isolated | CODE FI | Cannot verify whether reading indicates dangerous conductor carbonisation or benign electronic load. | Reg 643.3 BPG 4 Item 3.1 |
| Standard indoor socket-outlets installed to earlier edition without 30 mA RCD (Not outdoor) | CODE C3 | Installed to earlier standard; absence of additional protection is an improvement recommendation. | BPG 4 Item 4.1 Reg 411.3.3 |
| Absence of Surge Protection Device (SPD) in existing domestic distribution board | CODE C3 | Non-compliance with Reg 443.4.1 does not present immediate or potential danger to life. | Reg 443.4.1 BPG 4 Item 4.4 |
| Type AC RCD installed on domestic electronic circuits without blinding saturation | CODE C3 | Improvement recommended under Reg 531.3.3. Upgrade to C2 only if specific load blinds device. | Reg 531.3.3 BPG 4 Item 4.5 |
| Absence of circuit directory chart or RCD quarterly test warning notice | CODE C3 | Documentation defect; does not present immediate physical danger. | Reg 514.9.1 Reg 514.12.2 |
| No supplementary bonding in bathroom, with 30 mA RCD present and ADS verified | NO CODE | Regulation 701.415.2 explicitly permits omission of supplementary bonding when criteria are met. | Reg 701.415.2 BPG 4 Item 5.1 |
Inspector Notes: Nuances, Enclosures & Statutory Traps
Bench Note 1: Plastic vs Metal Consumer Units (Regulation 421.1.201)
Under BS 7671 Regulation 421.1.201, consumer units in domestic premises must have their enclosure manufactured from non-combustible material (typically sheet steel).
An existing plastic consumer unit that complies with earlier standards is not an automatic C2 unless:
- It shows evidence of thermal damage, overheating, or loose connections (Code C1 or C2 depending on exposure).
- It is installed directly beneath a domestic sole wooden escape route (staircase) where fire would trap occupants (Code C3 or C2 depending on risk assessment).
Where a plastic consumer unit is in good condition, correctly terminated, and not located in a sole escape route, it warrants no code or at most a Code C3 recommendation.
Bench Note 2: Main Protective Bonding to Incoming Plastic Utility Services
Inspectors frequently code missing main bonding as C2 without testing whether the incoming service is an extraneous conductive part. Under BS 7671 Regulation 411.3.1.2, only extraneous conductive parts require bonding.
Where an incoming water or gas service enters the premises in blue MDPE or yellow plastic pipework, it does not introduce true earth potential. Internal copper pipework connected to plastic incoming mains must not be bonded unless an insulation resistance measurement from the pipework to the main earthing terminal (MET) yields less than 25 kΩ (indicating external contact with earth). Bonding plastic-fed internal pipework unnecessarily creates an electrical hazard by introducing fault currents onto benign domestic pipes.
Bench Note 3: The PRS 2020 Statutory Clock on Code FI Observations
Under the Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020 (SI 2020/312), private landlords are under an absolute statutory obligation to investigate any condition marked FI within 28 days of the report date.
Once the investigation is completed, the landlord must obtain written confirmation from a qualified person certifying that the installation satisfies safety standards, and supply this confirmation to the tenant and local housing authority. Inspectors must never assign an FI code casually: it imposes a legal countdown and significant contractor costs on the property owner.
Bench Note 4: Type AC RCDs in Existing Installations: C3 vs C2 Nuance
BS 7671 Regulation 531.3.3 restricts Type AC RCDs to circuits where it is known that the load current contains no DC components. Virtually all modern domestic electronics produce small pulsed DC leakage currents that can saturate (blind) a Type AC magnetic toroid.
However, on an existing installation, the presence of a Type AC RCD is a Code C3 recommendation under BPG 4 Item 4.5. It is upgraded to Code C2 only if specific connected equipment is known to produce DC fault currents > 6 mA (such as an EV charging station or specific heat pump inverter) where the manufacturer explicitly mandates a Type A or Type B RCD and blinding risk is actively present.
Statutory Duty Matrix & Criminal Liabilities
An EICR is an evidentiary legal document. In the event of an electrical incident, the report schedule is presented in court to evaluate compliance under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, the Electricity at Work Regulations 1989, and the PRS Regulations 2020:
| Legislation & Clause | Duty Nature | Practical Legal Mandate on EICR Inspections | Statutory Defense & Penalties |
|---|---|---|---|
| EAWR 1989 Reg 4(1) | Absolute Duty | Dutyholders must ensure all systems are constructed and maintained to prevent danger at all times. | C1 or C2 defects left unaddressed represent direct criminal liability. Unlimited fine. |
| EAWR 1989 Reg 4(2) | Absolute Duty | Work activities and maintenance must not give rise to danger. Requires periodic engineering verification. | Executing regular EICR inspections forms primary evidence of proactive maintenance. |
| HSWA 1974 Section 3 | Qualified (SFAIRP) | Employers must conduct their undertaking so persons not in their employment are not exposed to health/safety risks. | Inspector must notify client immediately of C1 danger to protect third parties from fatal shock. |
| PRS Regs 2020 Reg 3 | Statutory Duty | Landlords must ensure electrical installations are inspected at intervals ≤ 5 years by a qualified person. | Failure to obtain Satisfactory report or complete remedials within 28 days: up to £30,000 civil penalty. |
| PRS Regs 2020 Reg 4 | Statutory Duty | Duty to complete investigative or remedial work for C1, C2, and FI within 28 days of report receipt. | Local housing authority may serve remedial notice and arrange emergency remedial action. |
| EAWR 1989 Reg 29 | Statutory Defense | Defendant must prove they took all reasonable steps and exercised all due diligence to avoid the offence. | Detailed contemporaneous EICR with exact measurements provides objective defense in criminal proceedings. |