Back to Tools Directory11kV Sequential Switching Schedules & Breaker Operations Guide

11kV Transformer IDMT Protection Curve & Discrimination Sizer

Prevent catastrophic upstream DNO 11kV feeder tripping during downstream LV faults. This tool evaluates IEC 60255 inverse definite minimum time (IDMT) curves, computes operating times across fault ranges, and evaluates the engineering guideline Δt ≥ 0.35s grading margin (NPAG / BS EN 60255-151) between 11kV relays and 400V air circuit breakers.

BS EN 60255-151 Discrimination Gate: To achieve total selectivity, upstream relays must maintain a grading margin of Δt ≥ 0.35 seconds over downstream devices, accounting for circuit breaker opening time (80ms), relay overshoot (50ms), CT saturation tolerance (100ms), and safety margin (120ms) per NPAG Chapter 9.
1-Click Quick Presets:Tap for instant on-site sizing
Select a preset above to auto-fill common circuit values
1. Upstream 11kV Overcurrent Relay
Relay Pickup Setting Tap (Is in Primary Amperes)100 A
Primary current pickup threshold on 11kV relay (typically 100% of CT primary).
0.150
Shifts the IDMT curve vertically to achieve selective time grading.
2. Secondary 400V Fault Level
Secondary Fault Current at 400V Busbar (kA)18.0 kA
Prospective symmetrical three-phase short-circuit level at 400V switchboard.
Relay: SI · Is=100AFault: 18.0 kA @ 400V
BASIS: BS EN 60255-151 §5.2 & NPAG CH 9IEC SI · TMS 0.150 · Δt ≥ 0.35s
Discrimination Grading Margin (Δt)
0.399s
11kV Relay Trip: 0.549 s · 400V Clear: 0.150 s
Reflected 11kV654.5 A
Operating PSM6.55 × Is
Target Gate≥ 0.35 s
1.0s0.5s0.2s0.0sFault (kA)
11kV Upstream Relay 400V Downstream ACB Operating Δt Point
Protection Coordination Guidance:
The downstream 400V ACB clears the fault in 150 ms before the 11kV upstream feeder relay trips at 549 ms.
Substation Parameters & Grading GatesStandard (1000 kVA · 100/5A CT · Downstream ACB 150ms · Target Δt ≥ 0.35s)
Show Full Mathematical Derivation (AM2 & Substation Design Standard)
BS 7671:2018+A4:2026
Step-by-step engineering workingTransparent first-principles maths
Worked Example: 1000 kVA 11kV/400V Substation Grading

Design Scenario: 1000 kVA 11kV/400V transformer with 100/5A CT, Standard Inverse (SI) relay with Is = 100 A and TMS = 0.15. Secondary fault current at 400V switchboard is 18 kA. Downstream ACB clears in 0.15 s.

Step 1: Transformation Ratio = 400 V / 11,000 V = 0.03636

Step 2: Reflected 11kV Fault Current = 18,000 A × (400 / 11000) = 654.5 A

Step 3: Plug Setting Multiplier (PSM) = 654.5 A / 100 A = 6.55 × Is

Step 4: IEC 60255 SI Formula Constants: k = 0.14, α = 0.02

Step 5: Denominator = (PSM)α - 1 = (6.545)&sup0;·&sup0;² - 1 = 0.03827

Step 6: Upstream 11kV Trip Time = (0.14 / 0.03827) × 0.15 = 0.549 s (549 ms)

Step 7: Discrimination Grading Margin (Δt) = 0.549 s - 0.150 s = 0.399 s (399 ms)

Step 8: Statutory Compliance Gate = Δt (399 ms) ≥ 350 ms benchmark → PASS (Selective Coordination Achieved)

Formula & factors cross-checked against BS 7671:2018+A4:2026. Free of black-box approximations.
Substation Engineering Practice Note:Grading calculations adhere to BS EN 60255-151:2009 and the Network Protection & Automation Guide (NPAG Chapter 9). Relay settings must account for transformer magnetising inrush current (typically 8× to 12× rated current for 100 ms) to avoid spurious tripping on energisation. When grading with downstream fuses, an Extremely Inverse (EI) curve provides closest thermal envelope tracking.

Regulation reference: BS EN 60255-151:2009 specifies overcurrent relay functional standards. BS 7671 Section 536 requires that protective devices be coordinated so that a fault is isolated by the device immediately upstream of the fault without causing uncoordinated tripping of upstream supplies.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is a 0.35s (350 ms) discrimination margin required between 11kV and 400V?

The 350 ms grading margin specified in NPAG Chapter 9 accounts for physical real-world tolerances across both protection systems: circuit breaker opening and arc extinguishing time (80 ms), relay overshoot time (50 ms), CT saturation and ratio errors (100 ms), and a safety allowance (120 ms). If the margin falls below 350 ms, an LV busbar fault risks causing sympathetic tripping of the upstream 11kV DNO feeder circuit breaker.

Which IEC 60255 curve should be selected for transformer protection?

The Standard Inverse (SI) curve is standard for general distribution networks. However, for transformer incomers subject to high energisation inrush, the Extremely Inverse (EI) curve is strongly recommended. Its steep I²t slope tracks transformer withstand and facilitates discrimination with downstream BS 88 high-rupturing-capacity (HRC) fuses.

Sparks Switchboard
Quick: